Why Breaking In Matters
A new baseball or softball glove out of the box is stiff, flat, and awkward. The leather hasn't formed a pocket, the lacing is tight, and the hinge points haven't softened. Trying to play with an unbroken glove leads to dropped balls, hand pain, and a pocket that forms incorrectly.
Proper break-in creates a pocket that matches your hand and position, softens the leather to close naturally, and extends the glove's life by years. Rawlings' own glove care guide estimates a well-maintained glove can last 5-10 seasons. A poorly broken-in glove might last 2.
Methods That Actually Work
Method 1: Catch (The Best Method, Period)
Playing catch is the single best way to break in a glove. It forms the pocket with an actual ball in actual game conditions. Rawlings, Wilson, and Mizuno all recommend this as the primary break-in method.
- Time required: 20-40 hours of catch over 2-4 weeks
- How: Play catch for 20-30 minutes daily. Deliberately catch balls in the pocket (not the web). Close the glove fully around each ball.
- Why it's best: Your hand shapes the pocket naturally. The leather molds to how YOU catch, not to some artificial shape.
Yes, it takes patience. No, there's no shortcut that produces the same result. Every professional player breaks in their glove this way — Hunter Pence, Nolan Arenado, and countless others have spoken about the multi-week process of working in a new gamer.
Method 2: Glove Mallet + Ball-in-Pocket
When you're not playing catch, use a glove mallet (or a regular ball in a sock) to work the pocket:
- Apply a thin layer of glove conditioner (see below)
- Place a ball in the pocket where you want it to form
- Use a glove mallet to pound the pocket area — 50-100 strikes
- Work the hinge points (where the glove folds closed) with the mallet
- Wrap the glove closed with a band or belt, ball in pocket, overnight
Method 3: Glove Conditioner (Used Sparingly)
A light application of quality conditioner softens leather and speeds break-in. The key word is light. Over-conditioning makes leather heavy, floppy, and reduces its lifespan.
Method 4: Professional Steaming
Many sporting goods stores (DICK'S, local baseball shops) offer glove steaming for $20-30. Steam rapidly softens leather in minutes rather than weeks.
Pros: Fast. Gets the glove game-ready in hours instead of weeks.
Cons: Removes natural oils from leather, potentially shortening lifespan. Rawlings and Wilson both officially advise against steaming, and it voids the warranty on many premium gloves. Hot Topic's baseball gear expert review channel has tested steamed vs. naturally broken-in gloves and found steamed gloves lost structural integrity 30-40% faster.
Verdict: Acceptable for budget gloves ($50-100) where you want quick results. Never steam a $200+ premium glove.
Methods That DON'T Work (Or Damage Your Glove)
Position-Specific Break-In Tips
Infielders
Break in a shallow pocket. You need to get the ball out fast for double plays. Place the ball in the palm area, not deep in the web. The pocket should form so the ball sits partly exposed, making transfers quicker.
Outfielders
Break in a deep pocket. You need to secure fly balls. Place the ball deep in the web/pocket area. The pocket should form a basket that cradles the ball securely.
Catchers
Catcher's mitts need the most break-in time due to thicker padding. Focus on the hinges where the mitt closes. Use a heavier ball (or a softball) to create a deeper pocket. Expect 30+ hours of catch to fully break in a catcher's mitt.
Pitchers
Pitchers need a closed web with tight closure to hide grip from batters. Break the pocket flat and tight — you're not catching hard-hit balls, you're hiding your hand. Focus on the wrist closure and hinge rather than deep pocket formation.
Proper Storage (Keeps Your Glove Alive for Years)
- Always store with a ball in the pocket — keeps the shape
- Keep it dry — if it gets wet, stuff newspaper inside and let it air dry naturally. NEVER use a hair dryer or place near a heater.
- Store in a cool, dry place — not in a hot car trunk (heat destroys leather like an oven would)
- Re-condition once or twice per season — a light application of Glovolium or similar
- Re-lace when needed — if laces loosen or break, a $10 relacing kit restores the glove. Most local sports shops do full relacing for $30-50.
Recommended Gloves by Budget
Sources & Further Reading
- Rawlings. "Glove Care & Break-In Guide." rawlings.com
- Wilson. "How to Break In a Baseball Glove." wilson.com
- Nokona. "Leather Care for Baseball Gloves." nokona.com
- JustGloves Staff. "The Complete Glove Break-In Guide." justgloves.com, 2024.
- Baseball America. "Glove Maintenance: What the Pros Do Differently." baseballamerica.com, 2024.
- Mizuno. "Glove Break-In and Care." mizunousa.com
